Most dangerous parts of Florida’s Don’t Say Gay law nullified in “monumental” settlement

Florida has reached a settlement with a cohort of LGBTQ+ rights groups challenging the state’s infamous Parental Rights in Education Act, commonly known as the “Don’t Say Gay” law. The settlement leaves the law in place but clarifies its language, which critics said was overly vague and could lead to violations of LGBTQ+ teachers’ and students’ constitutional rights.

Signed into law by Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) in 2022, the Don’t Say Gay law initially banned classroom instruction on sexuality and gender identity in grades K–3 but was expanded last year to ban instruction on those topics in all grades. Opponents of the law say its vague language has led to a chilling effect, curtailing any mention of LGBTQ+ people in Florida schools, forcing teachers back into the closet at work, and making it impossible for LGBTQ+ students to seek support or express their identities.

Related:

Plaintiffs in “Don’t Say Gay” lawsuit are still fighting to repeal the law

“Hope is an act of resistance and our families need all the hope that they can get.”

The settlement, reached on Monday, clarifies that the law only applies to classroom instruction and does not ban teachers or students from identifying as LGBTQ+ or mentioning their same-sex partners or family members in the classroom. Nor does it ban discussion of LGBTQ+ people and issues in lessons or student work. It also does not apply to library books.

Stay connected to your community

Connect with the issues and events that impact your community at home and beyond by subscribing to our newsletter.

Daily

Weekly

Good News

The law must be applied equally to classroom instruction on heterosexuality and cisgender identities, and it bans neither extracurricular activities like Gay-Straight Alliance clubs and plays featuring queer characters nor efforts to combat bullying based on sexual orientation and gender identity.

As part of the settlement, the state’s Department of Education is required to issue a memo to all of Florida’s school district boards clarifying the law’s scope and language.

In a press release, Equality Florida, Family Equality, and National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR) said the settlement “effectively nullifies the most dangerous and discriminatory impacts” of the Parental Rights in Education Act and “makes clear that the law must be applied neutrally and is no license to discriminate against or erase LGBTQ+ families.”

The settlement brings to an end a years-long legal battle between Florida and the LGBTQ+ advocacy organizations. Lawyers from Kaplan Hecker & Fink LLP and NCLR filed an initial complaint on behalf of Equality Florida, Family Equality, and students, parents, and a teacher in the state in May 2022 alleging the Don’t Say Gay law violated the first and fourteenth amendments of the Constitution. A Trump-appointed district court judge dismissed the complaint that September. The same judge dismissed an amended version of the complaint in February of last year.

Last March, the groups filed an appeal, and lead attorney Roberta Kaplan – who also represented rape victim E. Jean Carroll in her suits against Donald Trump – told the Associated Press this week that she was confident the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals would have ruled in their favor. But, she said, pursuing the challenge further would have taken several more years. “The last thing we wanted for the kids in Florida was more delay,” Kaplan said.

Kaplan said Monday’s settlement “re-establishes the fundamental principle, that I hope all Americans agree with, which is every kid in this country is entitled to an education at a public school where they feel safe, their dignity is respected and where their families and parents are welcomed.”

“It’s going to make a huge difference because the law was so vague that people stayed away from everything,” plaintiff Cecile Houry told the Tampa Bay Times. “Here it really defines what is not allowed, and everything else that is allowed. It’s going to change students’ experience.”

NCLR Legal Director Shannon Minter called the settlement “a monumental step forward in ensuring that every voice is heard and valued in our schools, and a critical victory in our ongoing fight for Floridian’s right to proudly say gay.”

“Today’s settlement reaffirms the rights of Florida’s students and teachers to openly discuss and learn about LGBTQ+ people, marking a victory for free expression and inclusivity for LGBTQ+ students, families, and teachers alike,” Minter said in a statement. “It ensures that conversations about LGBTQ+ identities are not banned from the classroom, promoting a much-needed culture of empathy and acceptance.”

DeSantis’s office also claimed the settlement was a win. “We fought hard to ensure this law couldn’t be maligned in court, as it was in the public arena by the media and large corporate actors,” state general counsel Ryan Newman said in a statement. “We are victorious, and Florida’s classrooms will remain a safe place under the Parental Rights in Education Act.”