US monument status doesn’t guarantee Stonewall Inn’s future

In this May 9, 2016 photo, pedestrians pass the Stonewall Inn, the iconic symbol of the modern gay rights movement across from Christopher Park, in New York. The area surrounding the Stonewall Inn, the site of a 1969 uprising widely viewed as the start of the fight for LGBT rights, is set to become a national monument. But that doesn’t mean the bar will always be a bar. AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews

NEW YORK — The area surrounding the Stonewall Inn is poised to become the first national monument dedicated to gay rights, but that doesn’t necessarily mean the property will always be a bar.

There’s actually nothing in the national monument designation or even the city’s landmark law to prevent New York‘s most famous gay bar from someday becoming a coffee shop, a frozen yogurt joint or anything else.

The tavern was the site of a 1969 uprising that is widely viewed as the start of the modern-day gay rights movement. The bar closed that same year, just months after patrons resisted a police raid.

The space was occupied for years by other businesses, including a bagel shop and a Chinese restaurant, before it reopened as a bar in the 1990s. In Stonewall’s current incarnation, under new owners since 2006, half the original space occupied by the bar is now a nail salon.

Co-owner Stacy Lentz said she and her partners bought the bar “to preserve history and make sure it wasn’t made into a Starbucks.” She said she is thrilled by the national monument discussions.

“This solidifies everything we have worked for to keep the legacy alive for generations to come,” she said.

The management company that owns the building did not respond to a message seeking comment.

The monument would be located in public spaces and possibly a small triangle of land across from the tavern.

But U.S. Rep. Jerrold Nadler, a New York Democrat who’s been pushing for the national monument designation for years, says nothing would force the Stonewall to remain a bar.

President Barack Obama is expected to move quickly to greenlight the monument, two people familiar with the administration’s plans told The Associated Press. They weren’t authorized to discuss the plans publicly and requested anonymity.

Nadler said the spot is worth recognizing because it would “tell the story of the United States,” as do park sites in Seneca Falls, New York, dedicated to the women’s rights movement, and Selma, Alabama, named for the civil rights movement.

The Stonewall is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and as a National Historic Landmark. It was designated a New York City landmark last year, the first time a site had received the designation because of its significance to LGBT history.

This Story Filed Under