When did the arguments against same-sex marriage become so silly?

When did the arguments against same-sex marriage become so silly?

Via Mark Joseph Stern at Slate, in an essay titled: “When Did the Arguments Against Gay Marriage Become So Silly?”

Mark Joseph Stern
Mark Joseph Stern

“The problem here, of course, is that an honest answer — ‘your honor, we believe gay people will destroy the marital institution altogether’ — would undermine the supposedly secular, animus-free nature of these arguments. In developing them, anti-gay activists began with a conclusion — gay people don’t deserve the rights that we straight people have — then worked backward, camouflaging each prejudiced premise with a supposedly neutral talking point.

“Under any kind of scrutiny, these theories instantly fall apart, revealing their bigoted, constitutionally impermissible core.


“And yet the inanity continues full-throttle, because gay marriage opponents have backed themselves into the corner they’ve always dreaded. They can’t give up their quest now — but they’re barred from citing the explanations that they truly believe, deep down, to be correct.

“The result is the current tailspin of idiocy, a shifting argument with rootless standards roaming from rationale to rationale in a desperate attempt to find shelter from the storm of progress swirling around it. It’s a pathetic display, but not an unpleasant one to witness. Stripped of all logic and reason, the argument against gay marriage has been reduced to gibberish. Enjoy the babbling while it lasts.”

Don't forget to share:

Support vital LGBTQ+ journalism

Reader contributions help keep LGBTQ Nation free, so that queer people get the news they need, with stories that mainstream media often leaves out. Can you contribute today?

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated

Arrest made in murder, burning of Fla. transgender woman

Previous article

Same-sex couples denied marriage licenses in South Carolina county

Next article