In Boulder County, Hall has issued more than 100 same-sex marriage licenses since the 10th Circuit’s June 25 ruling. Republican state Attorney General John Suthers sued Hall, the only Colorado clerk who defied the federal stay.
Hall argued that despite the stay, Colorado’s gay-marriage ban violates the U.S. Constitution.
Suthers said Hall’s behavior was causing “legal chaos” while the issue works its way through the courts. In a statement Thursday, Suthers said the issue “cries out for resolution by the state’s highest court.”
Nancy Leong, a University of Denver law professor, said Hartman’s ruling effectively allows government officials to sometimes disobey state law if they believe it violates the nation’s founding principles.
“I read his opinion to say a certain level of what we may call civil disobedience is permissible under the U.S. Constitution,” Leong said.
She said that, in the abstract, it seemed unlikely a judge would permit a government official to do something contrary to state law. But things play out differently in the notoriously liberal city known as “The Berkeley of the Rockies.”
“It’s Boulder,” Leong said.
Democratic Gov. John Hickenlooper appointed Hartman to the bench last year.
The decision from a three-judge 10th Circuit panel found states cannot deprive people of the fundamental right to marry simply because they choose partners of the same sex.
The ruling became law in the six states covered by the 10th Circuit: Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah and Wyoming. However, the panel immediately put the decision on hold pending an appeal.
On Wednesday, the Utah attorney general’s office announced it will challenge the panel’s ruling directly to the U.S. Supreme Court, meaning the nation’s highest court will have at least one same-sex marriage case on its plate when it returns in October.
There is no guarantee the high court will take the case, but situations like the one in Colorado add to the pressure for a final, definitive ruling on gay marriage in the U.S.
Same-sex marriage is legal in 19 states and the District of Columbia, but it’s in legal limbo in much of the rest of the nation. Seemingly every week, a new gay marriage ban gets struck down. Sometimes marriages start immediately; other times the rulings are put on hold and nothing happens.
In Colorado, District Judge C. Scott Crabtree on Wednesday became the 16th judge to strike down a state’s gay marriage ban in the past year, but he also put his decision on hold pending an appeal.
Crabtree wrote that the provisions in Colorado law clearly violate the state and U.S. constitutions. His ruling will be appealed by Suthers’ office, which defended the ban.
But in a statement Thursday, the governor made clear he didn’t want Suthers to appeal that ruling. Hickenlooper said he is “a strong advocate for marriage equality.”
“The decision on marriage by Judge Crabtree puts Colorado on the right side of history,” he said. “I have urged the attorney general not to appeal Judge Crabtree’s ruling.”
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.