The outing of University of Texas-Austin students to their parents as a consequence of a little-known Facebook privacy glitch has reignited longstanding concerns over the social network’s treatment of its LGBT users’ private information.
According to a report in the Wall Street Journal, the two students — Bobbi Duncan and Taylor McCormick — had placed highly restrictive privacy controls on the information , but were unintentionally outed by the head of their LGBT choir when they joined its Facebook group to get access to the rehearsal schedule:
The president of the chorus, a student organization at the University of Texas campus here, had added Ms. Duncan and Mr. McCormick to the choir’s Facebook group. The president didn’t know the software would automatically tell their Facebook friends that they were now members of the chorus.The two students were casualties of a privacy loophole on Facebook—the fact that anyone can be added to a group by a friend without their approval. As a result, the two lost control over their secrets, even though both were sophisticated users who had attempted to use Facebook’s privacy settings to shield some of their activities from their parents.
The consequences for Ms. Duncan and Mr. McCormick were dire — the former’s father “left vitriolic messages on her phone, demanding she renounce same-sex relationships, she says, and threatening to sever family ties,” causing her to spiral into a depression (she’s thankfully improved since). The latter’s dad “didn’t talk to his son for three weeks.”
The Journal notes that Facebook is making an admirable effort to make its privacy policies clearer to LGBT users, but this isn’t the first time the company’s opaque rules have outed LGBT individuals.
In 2009, Library of Congress employee Peter TerVeer was outed to his supervisor as a consequence of a Facebook policy change; he was met with a systematic pattern of discrimination that cost him his job and ultimately his home.
A glitch in Facebook’s advertising programming had previously sent confidential information on users’ sexual orientation to third-party advertisers.
Filed under: Texas













way to go, Zuckerberg…asshole
Glitch my ass.
Way to go to the parents, your kid is gay, get over it, not like he robbed a bank. And if you didn’t know before now, what does that say about you as a parent!
GRRR
Yeah, sure, “glitch”.
It could be a glitch.. They are changing Facebook up every few months it seems.. There’s going to be bugs. Or, some asshole at Facebook did this. But maybe we should not judge, and make wild assumptions. It could be anything.
I look forward to the day when people don’t have to hide who they are from their families.
I never really had the option of being in, so I really don’t feel any sympathy! It’s time to grow up boys and girls!
I’m not trying to sound like an ass, but it’s not a GLITCH. A “glitch” implies that its a malfunction that causes something to behave abnormally temporarily. Open groups on facebook have had that feature for a long while now and that feature will always remain. People should be cautious about what they put on the internet. If they don’t want any chance of being outed, don’t give anyone any chance of outing you.
Don’t loopholes just suck sometimes. That isn’t what gets me so flustered. It’s their parents. Seriously?! threatening to sever family ties just because your child is attracted to the same sex? What the hell kind of parent is that?! Parents should love and support their children 100% and be there for them when things are going bad for that child. Not shun them and push them away just because their gay. Way to be a good parent. Asshole. And if someone tries to bring up something biblical, well it says you should LOVE your kin. you may not like it, but their your blood for goodness sake….It’s not right man.
I like Jeff Futrel’s comments.. The real anger should be tendered towards the parents.. For their actions after the fact; also possibly not caring enough to really know who or what their children are. And, fostering a climate where their kids have to hide who they are from them…. Be angry at the parents – that is where the realy issues stem from…
that sir is a hacker and that hacker sir is a douchbag homophob who is a douchbag
OPEN Group/CLOSED group. That’s the diff.
Your on a social network like Facebook that is already hard to hide anything you post. So come on, really blaming Facebook? If you don’t want anything from YOU on the Internet then don’t create an account. But ppl always gonna talk about you so if it wast Facebook or not someone would of posted something so I’m sorry
How about you don’t put shit on facebook, or the internet period, that you dont want the whole world to know? And there is a feature that allows you to disable being added to groups by friends, I’ve personally used it. And if youre that in the closet about something, DONT HAVE A FACEBOOK TO BEGIN WITH. Someone somewhere is going to say something that will get back to someone else, thats how social media works. Just take some fucking responsibility!
^^ amen Jeremy!
Although its not fair to be outed, we’re all at a point in time when it is imperative and so very important, now more then ever, to come out and be yourself! I never had the chance to be “in the closet”! Stand up and stand out! It’s time!
Yikes!
This is how I decided to come out last week :)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xQVhmBA0E8I&feature=plcp
Be sure to watch it till the end and pass this message on, politics can be fun :)
Pass it on for LOVE and Marriage Equality in Washington State, APPROVE REFERENDUM 74!!
I go to UT Austin, am a member of Queer Chorus, and I know both of these people. Neither deserves what Facebook did to them, and what this is causing their families to do. Great fucking job, Facebook.
Convenient…
Facebook didn’t do anything to them except function as facebook does for everyone else. Maybe you should blame the person who added them to the group. Maybe they shouldn’t be in the queer chorus if theyre so in the closet. Nobody deserves to be hated or disowned for being gay, and their families are obviously shitty people. But you can’t blame facebook for everything just because you dont want to face reality.
The glitch also made messages prior to like 2011 or 2010 public. I could go on your profile and read some messages you guys recieved.
So yeah, it is partially Facebook’s fault that privste information is being leaked.
Facebook is a public, online, internet, cyberspace forum. Anything you put on here is subject to hy-jacking, hacking, and being spread all over virtual reality for all who choose to see. Don’t trust another person’s program with your life. Sorry. If you want to have clandestine activities, don’t participate unanimously on Facebook. Sorry to those with families that don’t understand them, but in the end, they will have to know. One way or another, they will have to know.
Karen, I completely agree with that. Also, it’s not Facebook’s fault that some parents are bigot assholes that need to just get over themselves and love their children just as they are because THAT is what it means to be a parent.
Nothing on the net, not just FB, is a secret. Its all out there,somewhere,waiting to be found.
Lezzies! Here is your inside scoop to lesbian: events; DJ’s; blogs; and everything NYC Lesbian all integrated craftily and easily on one facebook page! Add us!
http://www.facebook.com/lezmetrocity
You can not even SING in peace.